By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
Naven has no plans to be a ‘social media’ mayor for Manteca
Perspective
naven singh
Manteca Mayor Gary Singh and Mayor Elect Jacob Naven shake hands after a Manteca Interfaith Community Alliance event.

Jacob Naven has made it clear more than once.

As mayor, he won’t be answering “every question day and night on social media.”

That already has a few in the vast echo chamber of social media itching to pound their keyboards to slam Naven before he even takes the oath of office next month as Manteca’s 10th directly elected mayor.

People should try to restrain themselves from trying to end Naven’s proverbial honeymoon before the tie is even officially knotted.

From Day 1 of the official launch of his campaign, Naven has indicated there is a time for family, a time for his business, a time for his health, and a time to serve as mayor.

It’s not a criticism of Gary Singh, but Naven believes what his soon-to-be predecessor was doing — especially on social media — wasn’t scalable.

Singh seemed to make it a point to respond to everyone raising an issue on social media with him and/or city policies as well as actions.

To be clear, he also did so in person as well as with inquiries made by letter, phone, or email.

But social media — due to its very nature of being in the moment — has minimal filters and often minimal thought process or time for reflection.

And while Singh was driven as much by a desire to educate as he was to engage others with differing viewpoints as well as serve as someone who could help people find answers to their city questions, a social media presence comes at a heavy cost; time.

It is time that Naven sees taking away from his business, family, and health in addition to time that he’ll need to devote to the demands of the office whether it is interacting with staff or serving on what at times are endless council subcommittees and as city representatives on outside boards that have a big impact on Manteca’s ability to provide services for its residents.

Singh — as well as previous mayors — faced the same time issues.

But whether you agreed with his efforts on behalf of the City of Manteca, Singh took it to an entirely new level.

And it wasn’t just by being seemingly everywhere in Manteca from store openings to benefit dinners to talking with small groups of people.

His time on outside organizations such as chairing the San Joaquin Council of Governments and serving on its executive committee helped keep Manteca’s staff aware of transportation funding opportunities that Manteca was able to capitalize on.

And it’s not just the mayor that puts in a lot of time on city business away from twice a month meetings. So do other council members.

That said, Naven intends to devote 20 to 30 hour a week to fulfill his duties as Mayor of Manteca.

It is something he intends to do by striking a balance that works for him.

Did Singh up the bar too high?

Perhaps.

But as Naven points out there is only so far that bar can go.

Manteca is a general law city with a governance where the mayor has limited power.

Unlike some larger charter cities in California, the mayor on all matters is basically one of five votes.

Yes, the mayor does run the meetings, he sets the tone, he is the “official” elected face, his signature goes on documents the council passes, and he can do negotiations — as a team with another council member — with developers.

But at the end of the day, he is just one of five votes.

It’s a point that way too many fail to grasp.

As an example, there is already carping on Naven for not doing anything to get Immigration & Custom Enforcement agents out of Manteca.

Besides the fact Naven hasn’t been sworn in yet, the mayor has no control over what ICE does just like he has no control over the school district, the State of California, or whether Trader Joe’s opens a store in Manteca.

The mayor can work with all those entities in a bid to get them to pursue a certain path, but he has no authority as one person to make them do anything.

Naven understands he has a learning curve.

It is why he’s devoted what he has estimated to be 1,000 hours in the past year to meet with city department heads and tag along with employees on their daily rounds — think solid waste collectors — to get a better handle on municipal functions and the jobs city employees do.

Singh put himself out there.

And in doing so, it made him a large target.

This, in a way, is about lowering one’s expectations to match reality.

Manteca has a weak mayor system.

There is only so much a mayor can do.

Neither Singh or Naven are the Wizard of Oz.

By Singh putting himself out there as much as he did, it gave birth to Manteca’s version of the Greek chorus that repeatedly chanted “it’s Gary’s fault.”

And almost every time it’s because Singh took the time on social media to explain why the city did things a certain way.

More often than not, people didn’t like the answers as they didn’t fit their mindset.