By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
CLOSING IN ON 30,000 RED LIGHT TICKETS
Manteca may lower the red light running penalty next month
red light camera
A red light camera on North Main Street at Northgate Drive.

Manteca this month is likely to issue its 30,000th red light ticket since May 2025.

That includes 1,344 tickets in October that carry a $490 fine and have been known in some cases to increase insurance premiums by as much as 20 percent.

The days of the $490 ticket, though, may be numbered.

Police Chief Stephen Schluer — following council directive — is expected to present how the city could switch to lower priced tickets either at the Dec. 1 or Dec. 15 council meeting.

The proposal to switch red light running at intersections with cameras from a moving violation to a misdemeanor citation was championed in October by Councilman Mike Morowit.

“A lower fine makes sense because its fair to folks that don’t realize they are making a mistake and it doesn’t impact their auto insurance,” Morowit said.

One of the biggest problems are motorists that don’t understand they need to come to a complete stop under California law before making a right run on a red light.

Manteca Police, in order to avoid issuing thousands upon thousands of more red light tickets than the 28,868 they already have, doesn’t issue right turn red light tickets unless the driver is going above 10 mph.

Morowit noted the goal is to educate drivers to stop the unsafe behavior.

Depending upon the driver’s DMV record, a red light ticket can lead to higher insurance premiums and even the loss of driving privileges.

Morowit believes the citation process is more appropriate than the moving violation because:

*It doesn’t require going through the time consuming court process.

*It doesn’t go on driving records.
*It still penalizes unsafe driving habits and brings the behavior to the attention of drivers cited.

*It doesn’t require having a police officer to review tickets and match the faces of drivers Wirth DMV photos as the citations are based on license plate numbers just like toll charges.

*Unpaid fines must be paid before vehicles can be re-registered.

*It steps up the penalty for those that fail to adjust their driving habits to follow state law.

The switch to citations handled in house by the city and not the courts would not mean repeat offenders — those drivers who keep running the red lights despite knowing the consequences after being ticketed — wouldn’t pay a heavier burden

That’s because the civil penalties would be:

*$100 for the first violation.

*$200 for the second violation within three years.

*$350 for the third violation within three years.

*500 for the fourth, and each subsequent violations, within three years.

And if someone refuses to pay a citation within a set period, their vehicle can be impounded resulting in impound fees and storage fees on top of paying the fines to get their vehicle back

The only possible road block would be making sure the change would not subject the city to legal action regarding the contract they signed with American Traffic Systems to install and operate the cameras.

On the surface, switching to the $100 citation would still allow the city to cover the contract charges plus have money that can be plowed back into additional traffic enforcement measures.

The only entities that would “lose” would be the State of California and charges that help pay to operate the court system.

The city, under state law, can’t lose money in any given year with a red light camera contract. That means if the city doesn’t collect enough to cover the cost within a 12-month period, that amount is forgiven.

To contact Dennis Wyatt, email dwyatt@mantecabulletin.com